+- BAJR Federation Archaeology (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk)
+-- Forum: BAJR Federation Forums (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: The Site Hut (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: When is a ditch a gully? (/showthread.php?tid=4108)
When is a ditch a gully? - BAJR - 5th October 2011
Yup, I would cast my lot in with the general Ditch is a bigger cut, which although it can carry water in a drainage type way is more associated with boundary.
while a gully (in an anthropogenic form) is a shallow drainage channel. often rounded of base ? which will always carry water and although it can be used as a boundary, this is not a primary function.
Oh hell.... good question!
When is a ditch a gully? - Wax - 5th October 2011
If I can lie in it its a ditch, if I cant then its a gully
When is a ditch a gully? - P Prentice - 5th October 2011
and any number of experienced diggers working on the same feature and who have worked together for yonks will still not know the difference when it s raining, or nearly time to clean up, or ........
When is a ditch a gully? - Dinosaur - 5th October 2011
Wax Wrote:If I can lie in it its a ditch, if I cant then its a gully
R u particularly wide or just concerned about bits sticking out and snipers, or just enjoy getting muddier than everyone else?
Can't see many academics applying that particular test! }
When is a ditch a gully? - vulpes - 5th October 2011
I think Wax is referring to whether 'skiving depth' is achievable!
When is a ditch a gully? - Jack - 5th October 2011
It doesn't really matter as long as your consistent and put the measurements of the feature in question in the narrative
When is a ditch a gully? - Dirty Dave Lincoln - 5th October 2011
A problem with recording and interpreting features is not knowing a) at what level they were originally cut from, and b) how much has been lost through truncation/ploughing. This often gives a distorted view of the size of features, and leads to different people using various terms as 'interpretation'.
A good example being post-holes, that after machining down to natural, only survive in depths of 50mm (for example) and not being recognized as 'real' due to lack of depth-untill you point out that they could have been cut from half a metre higher!!:face-huh::face-thinks:
When is a ditch a gully? - Dinosaur - 5th October 2011
Hence my preferred approach relating to function - I've currently got 'ditches' ranging in size from 0.5 - 20+m wide in my collection of active projects, size isn't everything...
When is a ditch a gully? - GnomeKing - 5th October 2011
Concise Oxford : 4 ; the remains of a truncated ditch:face-thinks:...
When is a ditch a gully? - Wax - 5th October 2011
Dinosaur's ditches ranging from 0.5m to 20m wide all fit my ditch category as I bet I could lie down in all of them (when excavated) I am not particularly wide. Some ditches are quite comfortable and were some times used for shelter by travellers caught out at night. The can provide somewhere out of the wind to light a fire.
Function might be a better definition than size but how do you know what the original function was, at best you are making an assumption based on the evidence?