Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - deadlylampshade - 7th June 2011
gwyl Wrote:that's the A40 for you
although why you'd want to go to Cheltenham eludes me. ..
I can exclusively reveal that the Cheltenham spa has nothing to do with Minerva and natural springs and wot not...it's a fountain of eternal youth based on Guinness! :0There is a special Festival every year which is a rite of spring...fabulous. You really should try it some day...}
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - gwyl - 7th June 2011
the icing on the cake, for me, is that there was a 'property boom' during the Neolithic. what?!?!?!
so, from this, the entire focus and purpose of British archaeology can be boiled down to tracking a flint-knapping, hazelnut-eating, rock-rolling bunch of hairy-arsed immigrant farmers developing into a daily mail-reading diying dyspeptic bunch of home-owners. triffic.
god help us.
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - moreno - 7th June 2011
Some food for thought:
http://antiquity.ac.uk/projgall/levy/
Some articles (follow the links) regarding the use and nuances involving Baysian Calibration. As Tom Wilson pointed out, Baysian Calibration has been around for awhile, and not everyone agrees on how it's applied.
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - P Prentice - 7th June 2011
gwyl Wrote:all of which is true
but what it all comes down to is that a lot of prehistory is 'complete bollocks'; all this rubbish about increasing complexity and hierarchies and centralisation of production and sacred landscapes of the eternal naval; frankly it's all dungeons and dragons and arthur and the medievalisation of prehistory. 'complete bollocks'.
it does go some way (that is to say a very long way) to explaining why my pot dates read one thing, my stratigraphy agrees but not entirely and my radiocarbon dates say wahey it's all prehistory, innit and i'm left holding a baby that is a tradition that extends through time and across space
prehistory is 'complete bollocks'
maybe that'll find it's way into the publication report, even at this late hour of the day
best get back to medieval smithing and potting
proper archaeology; not makeyuppyology
one last time 'COMPLETE BOLLOCKS'
OOOOOOOOOOoooooooooohh that feels good
Next time you are putting in a WSI on a prehistoric site i will take great pleasure in reminding you of this statement - you scrofulous medieval peasant
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - Unitof1 - 7th June 2011
Quote:
so, from this, the entire focus and purpose of British can be boiled down to tracking a flint-knapping, hazelnut-eating, rock-rolling bunch of hairy-arsed immigrant farmers developing into a daily mail-reading diying dyspeptic bunch of home-owners. triffic.
but now also an eh dictate. Why is eh doing baysian statistics? Will it gloss over not shedualling any more cuasewayed encloures thingys?-
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - P Prentice - 7th June 2011
e h, like most of the rest of us, is probably interested in moving forward the study of our past rather than finding ways to fleece lilold laddies
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - gwyl - 7th June 2011
and some more food for thought
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/archaeology/a-computer-dating-revolution-of-the-archaeological-kind-2293393.html
although why shouldn't EH be doing Baysian stats; someone has to...
and i shan't be the one.
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - Unitof1 - 7th June 2011
Apart from agriculture came by boat to kent and then decided that for the rest of Britain it would walk from there bollocks
Eh are also landowners, owners of monuments and statutory advisors to planning applications. Do they start saying well actually causewayed thingys are just some isolated property development which never caught on and have little archaeological significances in the greater scheme of things, so put up an outer town super market, we refuse to schedule another one if it is found, just get some more dates to prove our theory?.
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - P Prentice - 7th June 2011
Unitof1 Wrote:Apart from agriculture came by boat to kent and then decided that for the rest of Britain it would walk from there bollocks
Eh are also landowners, owners of monuments and statutory advisors to planning applications. Do they start saying well actually causewayed thingys are just some isolated property development which never caught on and have little archaeological significances in the greater scheme of things, so put up an outer town super market, we refuse to schedule another one if it is found, just get some more dates to prove our theory?.
you are a scream today unit, a conspiritortionist par excellence. no need for any research anywhere on anything just do evaluations eh?
Prehistory is 'complete bollocks' says radiocarbon expert - gwyl - 7th June 2011
Unitof1 Wrote:Apart from agriculture came by boat to kent and then decided that for the rest of Britain it would walk from there bollocks
well, you know how these things are. agriculture probably took a little while to catch on outside of the cosmopolitan southeast, like cappucinos, crystal balls, spelling and all the other great stuff we got from the Romans over the years
Unitof1 Wrote:Eh are also landowners, owners of monuments and statutory advisors to planning applications. Do they start saying well actually causewayed thingys are just some isolated property development which never caught on and have little archaeological significances in the greater scheme of things, so put up an outer town super market, we refuse to schedule another one if it is found, just get some more dates to prove our theory?.
well, funny you should mention that
http://www.cityam.com/news-and-analysis/allister-heath/broadgate-symbol-red-tape-britain
you've gotta laugh, innit Unit
tho' to be honest, i think the Westway and elevated roadways should also be included in EH's scheduling
there's too much old rubbish in there
|