+- BAJR Federation Archaeology (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk)
+-- Forum: BAJR Federation Forums (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: The Site Hut (http://www.bajrfed.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Fisticuffs at Woodhenge (metaphorically speaking) (/showthread.php?tid=3627)
Fisticuffs at Woodhenge (metaphorically speaking) - BAJR - 12th December 2010
Woodhenge: Is this one of the greatest discoveries of archaeology...or a simple farmer's fence?
Vince Gaffney and Mike Pitts square up over Hexagonal 'fence' or 'henge' the smaller dots inside the larger blobs (to be technical!)
[ATTACH=CONFIG]787[/ATTACH]
The discovery of a wooden version of Stonehenge – a few hundred yards from the famous monument – was hailed as one of the most important archaeological finds for decades.
But now experts are at loggerheads after claims that what was thought to be a Neolithic temple was a rather more humble affair – in fact the remains of a wooden fence.
One leading expert on Stonehenge criticised the announcement of the ‘remarkable’ find in July as ‘hasty’ and warned it could become a ‘PR embarrassment’.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1337890/Woodhenge-Is-greatest-discoveries-archaeology--simple-farmers-fence.html#ixzz17vH63X5A
But now experts are at loggerheads after claims that what was thought to be a Neolithic temple was a rather more humble affair – in fact the remains of a wooden fence.
One leading expert on Stonehenge criticised the announcement of the ‘remarkable’ find in July as ‘hasty’ and warned it could become a ‘PR embarrassment’.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1337890/Woodhenge-Is-greatest-discoveries-archaeology--simple-farmers-fence.html#ixzz17vH63X5A
Vince Gaffney and Mike Pitts square up over Hexagonal 'fence' or 'henge' the smaller dots inside the larger blobs (to be technical!)
[ATTACH=CONFIG]787[/ATTACH]
Fisticuffs at Woodhenge (metaphorically speaking) - Law - 13th December 2010
Isn't Woodhenge a large Neolithic monument north east of Stonehenge discovered in the 1920s?
Fisticuffs at Woodhenge (metaphorically speaking) - BAJR - 13th December 2010
Another one... yes
OR is it??
Fisticuffs at Woodhenge (metaphorically speaking) - Jack - 13th December 2010
They aint gonna know for sure until someone excavates it!
Or has someone done so?
Got bored of the article, but did laugh at the first comment critising archaeologist for mis-interpretating the relationship between a barrow and encircling posts...saying that water was important to neolithic people, hence the 'fence' is later!!???
Fisticuffs at Woodhenge (metaphorically speaking) - the invisible man - 13th December 2010
First up, it's a pity some people can't tell radar from mag!
Secondly, I love the little picture of a Neolithic man. He appears to be sitting outside a stone-walled roundhouse, holding a Beaker and wearing a metal buckled belt (and possiblly metal bracelets, armband and pendant but they could be leather!)
I assumed that the 'fenceposts' are actually the larger anomalies, Hosty. As Vince Gaffney points out, they are rather large for fencepost holes. When he says there was no metal in the holes, I presume he means that they have not been excavated, but there is no obviously ferrous reponse. The anomalies look very strong though, and have negative haloes: there's something in there, even if it's only magnetically contrasting dirt. Either way, I am not convinced that a lack of metal confirms a neolithic date.
Fisticuffs at Woodhenge (metaphorically speaking) - BAJR - 13th December 2010
Sounds like you are on the fence there
But oh yes the Neolithic visitor was a hoot!
oh... the 'fence' may be the smaller grey dots within the larger annomoly.
No doubt about that,